Menu for East Hampton
EAST HAMPTON • DINNER
◆ Seafood Appetizers ◆
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
horseradish & cocktail sauce
GF
32
Fried Calamari
chili aioli & cocktail sauce
26
◆ Warm Appetizers ◆
Soup du Jour
18
Grilled Artichoke
lemon beurre blanc
GF
19
Steak Tip Skewers
(2pc) with shallots & peppers
28
◆ Salads ◆
Classic Caesar Salad
add grilled chicken breast (+9)
18
Lucky’s Salad
shrimp, bacon, avocado & roquefort
GF
29
Wedge of Iceberg
cucumber, bacon, blue cheese
GF
20
Jimmy the Greek Salad
cucumber, tomato, feta, olive
GFV
22
◆ Lucky Hour ◆
Oysters
5pm - 6pm
2
Prime Sliders
5pm - 6pm
5
Mr. Lucky
tequila, lime & st. germain, served up (5pm - 6pm)
13
Glass Wine
5pm - 6pm (select wine by the glass*)
13
◆ Steaks & Chops ◆
Aged USDA PRIME Served Exclusively
Petit Filet Mignon7oz
usda prime served exclusively
GF
58
New York Strip Steak12oz
usda prime served exclusively
GF
68
Porterhouse, SLICED28oz
usda prime served exclusively
GF
165
Bone-in Rib Eye, SLICED20oz
usda prime served exclusively
GF
132
◆ Sauces ◆
Béarnaise ◆ Red Wine & Shallots ◆ Peppercorn Cream ◆ Fresh Truffle Butter ◆ Chimichurri
◆ Special Steaks ◆
Aged USDA PRIME Served Exclusively
Steak Frites
5oz filet mignon & peppercorn cream
GF
50
Gene's Filet7oz
red wine shallot & horseradish
GF
60
NY Strip Pepper Steak12oz
peppercorn cream
GF
70
NY Strip with Roquefort12oz
GF
80
◆ Mains ◆
Prime Burger
cheddar, lto, garlic aioli & fries
29
Veggie Burger
lto & fries
V
25
Half Chicken
roast vegetables and au jus
GF
35
Market Fish of the day
fresh catch of the day
GF
MP
Chicken Parmesan
35
Market Vegetable Risotto
GFV
29
◆ Sides ◆
Skinny Onion Rings
V
20
French Fries
VVGGF
15
Half Onion Rings / Half Fries
V
20
Herbie's Potato Skins
sour cream & chives
GFV
18
Braised Mushrooms
GFV
20
Green Beans
red wine vinaigrette
GFVG
16
Sautéed Spinach
garlic & oil
GFVG
16
Creamed Spinach
GFV
17
Mac and Cheese
V
18
Mashed Potatoes
GFV
16
◆ Cocktails ◆
Lucky’s Martini Service
gin or vodka, shaken tableside
25
Mr. Lucky
tequila, lime & st. germain, served up
19
Carousel
bourbon, demerara, peychaud’s & green chartreuse, on a big rock
22
Yolita
yola mezcal, lime, passionfruit & chile, on the rocks
19
The Lucky Lychee
vodka, lemon, lychee & melon, served up
22
◆ Beer ◆
North Fork Brewing Co (Draft)
lager “hold me closer tiny lager”
13
Talea (Draft)
hazy ipa
13
Duvel (Bottle)
belgian strong blonde
13
Guinness (Can)
stout
8
◆ Non-Alcoholic ◆
Sarah's Spritz
hibiscus, ginger, mint, lime & soda, highball
12
Faux-Nee Sbagliato
giffard n/a apertif, soda, orange
12
Erdinger (Bottle)
n/a weissbier
10
Best Day Brewing Co (Can)
n/a kölsch
11
◆ Sparkling Wine ◆
NV Per Ora Prosecco
veneto, italy *
16
◆ White Wine ◆
2025 Alta Monte Pinot Grigio
alto adige, italy *
16
2024 Stolpman Vineyards Sauvignon Blanc
santa barbara county, california
19
2023 Pride Mountain Vineyards Chardonnay
napa valley, california
25
◆ Red Wine ◆
2023 Walt Vineyards Pinot Noir
anderson valley, california *
19
2023 Castello di Volpaia Chianti Classico
tuscany, italy
22
2023 Bedrock Wine Co. Cabernet Sauvignon
sonoma county, california
27
◆ Vodka ◆
Wheatley by Buffalo Trace (House)
17
Absolut Citron
19
Absolut Elyx
19
Beluga
19
Grey Goose
19
Tito’s
17
Belvedere
19
Ketel One
19
◆ Gin ◆
Beefeater (House)
17
Tanqueray
17
Plymouth
19
Bombay Sapphire
20
Hendricks
18
Monkey 47
22
◆ Tequila & Mezcal ◆
Casco Viejo Blanco (House)
tequila
17
Casco Viejo Reposado (House)
tequila
17
Herradura Añejo
tequila
28
El Tesoro Blanco
tequila
24
El Tesoro Reposado
tequila
28
Casa Dragones Blanco
tequila
28
Casa Dragones Reposado
tequila
50
Casa Dragones Añejo
tequila
55
Don Julio 1942
tequila
60
Clase Azul Plata
tequila
50
Lalo Blanco
tequila
20
Casa Azul Blanco
tequila
21
Casa Azul Reposado
tequila
24
Casa Azul Añejo
tequila
32
Yola Mezcal (House)
mezcal
17
Yola Pechuga
mezcal
35
Del Maguey Vida
mezcal
17
Ilegal Joven
mezcal
20
Siete Misterios
mezcal
18
Sotol Romo
sotol
22
◆ Rum ◆
El Dorado 3 (House)
18
Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva
18
Diplomatico Mantuano
18
Mount Gay Eclipse
21
◆ Scotch Whisky ◆
Johnnie Walker Red Label
blended scotch
17
Johnnie Walker Black Label
blended scotch
19
Johnnie Walker Blue Label ‘Ice Chalet’
blended scotch
84
Ardbeg 10 Single Malt
islay single malt
29
Glenfiddich 12 Single Malt
speyside single malt
25
Laphroaig 10 Single Malt
islay single malt
25
Macallan 12 Sherry Oak
speyside single malt
28
Lagavulin 16 Single Malt
islay single malt
40
The Balvenie 12 Single Malt
speyside single malt
30
Aberlour 16 Single Malt
speyside single malt
50
◆ Bourbon ◆
Pinhook (House)
bourbon
17
Basil Hayden
bourbon
25
Blanton’s
bourbon
35
Buffalo Trace
bourbon
18
Michter’s Small Batch
bourbon
18
Woodford Reserve
bourbon
18
◆ Rye ◆
Pinhook (House)
rye whiskey
17
Old Overholt
rye whiskey
18
Knob Creek 7
rye whiskey
19
Knob Creek 10
rye whiskey
27
Michter’s Small Batch Rye
rye whiskey
18
◆ Whiskey ◆
Jameson
irish whiskey
19
Dewar’s White Label
blended scotch whisky
19
Crown Royal
canadian whisky
19
◆ Japanese Whisky ◆
Suntori Toki
17
Hibiki Harmony
33
Nikka Miyagikyo Single Malt
35
Yamazaki 12 Single Malt
52
◆ Cognac & Port ◆
Pierre Ferrand 1840
cognac
18
Kopke 20 Year Tawny
port
24
◆ Aperitif & Liqueur ◆
Campari
16
Aperol
16
Chambord
16
Frangelico
16
Mr Black
17
Lucano Limoncello
17
Lucano Sambuca
17
Drambuie
17
Disaronno Amaretto
18
Nonino Grappa
20
Lillet Blanc
16
Carpano Antica Formula
20
◆ Amaro ◆
Averna
17
Fernet Branca
17
Braulio
18
Cynar 70
18
Nonino
19
◆ Dessert ◆
Flourless Chocolate Cake
raspberries & vanilla ice cream
19
Creme Brulée
seasonal fruit
19
Cheesecake
berries & whipped cream
19
Chocolate Chip Cookie
vanilla ice cream
12
Gene's Affogato
espresso & vanilla ice cream
12
Salted Turtle Sundae
whipped cream, pecans, caramel & chocolate
17
Market Sorbet
seasonal sorbet
12
◆ sparkling ◆
NV
PIERRE SPARR CREMANT D’ALSACE
BRUT RESERVE, FR NV
72
NV
PER ORA
PROSECCO, VENETO, ITALY NV
65
NV
CHARLES LEFITTE
CUVEE SPECIALE BRUT, CHAMPAGNE, FR NV
85
NV
J. LASSALLE BLANC D’ASSEMBLAGE
BRUT CHAMPAGNE, FR NV
90
NV
BILLECART SALMON
LE EXTRA BRUT ROSE, CHAMPAGNE, FR NV
225
◆ white ◆
loire
NV
ISABELLE GARRAULT
‘LES GRANDS MONTS’ SANCERRE 2025
95
NV
GERARD BOULAY CHAVIGNOL
SANCERRE 2024
95
NV
NOEL ET JEAN-LUC RAIMBAULT SANCERRE
2025
85
burgundy
NV
MAISON GAUTHERIN VILLAGE SIGNATURE
CHABLIS 2022
80
NV
ELENI & EDOUARD VOCORET SÉCHET, CHABLIS
1ER CRU 2023
250
NV
FRANCOIS LABET VIELLES VIGNES
BOURGOGNE 2022
85
NV
JOSEPH COLIN MES SEPT TERROIRS
SAINT-AUBIN 2024
185
NV
DOMAINE FAIVELEY
LE VALLON BLANC, MERCUREY 2021
110
italy
NV
ELENA WALCH
PINOT GRIGIO, ALTO ADIGE 2024
75
NV
ALTA MONTE
PINOT GRIGIO, ALTO ADIGE 2025
65
NV
TERRE NERE CARRICANTE
ETNA BIANCO, SICILY 2025
80
usa
NV
STOLPMAN VINEYARDS
SAUVIGNON BLANC, SANTA BARBARA, CA 2024
75
NV
PRIDE MOUNTAIN VINEYARDS
CHARDONNAY, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2023
100
NV
FRANK FAMILY VINEYARDS
CHARDONNAY, RESERVE, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2023
150
south africa
NV
BOSMAN VINEYARDS CHENIN BLANC
‘OPTENHORSE’, WELLINGTON 2023
89
◆ rosé ◆
NV
WOLFFER ESTATE
‘GOLD LABEL’, SOFO, NY, USA 2025
55
NV
PEYRASSOL
‘LES TEMPLIERS’, PROVENCE, FR 2024
76
NV
DOMAINE
LA BERNARDE ‘LES HAUTS DU LUC’ CÔTES DE PROVENCE, FR 2025
60
◆ red ◆
burgundy
NV
DOMAINE FAIVELEY
LES SAINT-GEORGES, NUITS-SAINT-GEORGES 1ER CRU 2021
550
NV
PIERRE GIRARDIN AUX CHAMPS PERDRIX
VOSNE-ROMANÉE 2021
450
NV
DOMAINE JEAN FERY SOUS
LA CABOTTE, SAVIGNY-LES-BEAUNE 2022
110
NV
DOMAINE DUREUIL-JANTHIAL MERCUREY
2022
130
beaujolais
NV
ANNE-SOPHIE DUBOIS
LES COCOTTES, FLEURIE 2024
90
bordeaux
NV
CHÂTEAU DE CAMENSAC HAUT-MÉDOC
2009
155
NV
CHÂTEAU
LES ORMES DE PEZ SAINT-ESTÈPHE 2018
100
NV
CHÂTEAU COS D’ESTOURNEL SAINT-ESTÈPHE
2015
550
NV
CHÂTEAU LAFITE ROTHSCHILD PAUILLAC
2016
2100
NV
CHÂTEAU GRUAUD LAROSE SAINT-JULIEN
2005
495
NV
CHÂTEAU CANTENAC-BROWN MARGAUX
2016
240
NV
CHÂTEAU LABÉGORCE MARGAUX
2017
110
NV
CHÂTEAU ROC DE CAMBES CÔTE DE BOURG
2022
180
NV
CHÂTEAU TERTRE RÔTEBOEUF SAINT-EMILION
GRAND CRU 2019
400
rhone / south
NV
CLUSEL-ROCH CHAMPON
CÔTE-RÔTIE 2021
285
NV
DOMAINE SANTA DUC
‘LES AUBES’, VACQUEYRAS 2022
95
NV
CLOS DU MONT-OLIVET
VIEILLES VIGNES, CÔTES DU RHÔNE 2023
60
NV
DOMAINE DUSEIGNEUR ’MATTEO’
CHATEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2020
110
NV
DOMAINE GALEVAN SAINT GEORGES
CHATEAUNEUF-DU-PAPE 2020
200
NV
CHÂTEAU DE GOURGAZAUD
‘CUVEE MORGANE’, MINERVOIS, LANGUEDOC-ROUSSILLON 2018
60
pinot noir
NV
KISTLER RUSSIAN RIVER VALLEY
CA 2024
165
NV
TYLER WINERY STA. RITA HILLS
CA 2023
80
NV
PRESQU’ILE WINERY
PINOT NOIR, SANTA BARBARA, CA 2024
75
cabernet sauvignon
NV
BEDROCK WINE CO. SONOMA COUNTY
CA 2023
110
NV
BONANZA BY CAYMUS
LOT 9, NAPA VALLEY NV
68
NV
THREE BY WADE NAPA VALLEY
CA 2022
75
NV
THE MASCOT BY HARLAN NAPA VALLEY
CA 2022
400
NV
METAPHORA NAPA VALLEY
CA 2009
225
NV
NINE SUNS PRITCHARD HILL
NAPA VALLEY, CA 2014
480
NV
O’SHAUGHNESSY NAPA VALLEY
CA 2022
180
NV
TURLEY ESTATE
NAPA VALLEY, CA 2023
135
NV
FORTUNATE SON
‘THE DREAMER’, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2021
372
NV
GRGICH HILLS OLD VINES 100TH BIRTHDAY
YOUNTVILLE, NAPA VALLEY 2019
450
NV
EISELE VINEYARD ESTATE
NAPA VALLEY, CA 2014
795
more grapes & blends
NV
GRGICH HILLS
ZINFANDEL, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2019
105
NV
HOURGLASS ESTATE
MERLOT/CABERNET/PETIT SYRAH, ‘RED BLEND III’, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2023
145
NV
MELVILLE ESTATE
SYRAH, ‘DONNA’S’, SANTA BARBARA, CA 2019
145
NV
CHAPPELLET
CABERNET FRANC, NAPA VALLEY, CA 2021
285
spain
NV
HERMANOS DE PECIÑA TEMPRANILLO
GRAN RESERVA, RIOJA 2016
115
NV
LA RIOJA ALTA TEMPRANILLO
VIÑA ARDANZA, RESERVA, RIOJA 2020
95
piedmont
NV
CA’ DEL BAIO
‘AUTINBEJ’ BARBARESCO 2022
76
NV
CASTELLO DI VERDUNO BAROLO
2022
140
NV
GAJA
‘DAGROMIS’ BAROLO 2020
295
NV
MALVIRA BOIOLO
BAROLO 2013
150
NV
PAOLO SCAVINO
‘ROCCHE DELL’ANNUNZIATA’ BAROLO 2005
725
veneto
NV
CANTINA VALPANTENA TORRE DEL FALASCO AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA
2021
90
NV
DAL FORNO ROMANO VALPOLICELLA SUPERIORE
2018
342
tuscany
NV
CASTELLO DI VOLPAIA CHIANTI CLASSICO RISERVA
2020
125
NV
CASTELLO DI VOLPAIA CHIANTI CLASSICO
2023
90
NV
SAN FABIANO CALCINAIA
‘CELLOLE’ CHIANTI CLASSICO 2019
125
NV
CIACCI PICCOLOMINI ROSSO DI MONTALCINO
2024
75
NV
MOCALI BRUNELLO DI MONTALCINO
2021
115
argentina
NV
LA IGRIEGA MALBEC
‘PRINCIPIO’, MENDOZA, AR 2024
60
Menu is temporarily unavailable. Please try refreshing or call us directly.
GFGluten Free
VVegetarian
VGVegan
DFDairy Free
Last Updated: October 31, 2026
LIVE SYNCConsumer Advisory: Consuming Raw or Cooked Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish or Eggs may increase the risk of foodborne illness if you have certain medical conditions.